Tuesday, April 2, 2013

David Bressoud: "Good Teaching"

Check out David Bressoud's results about instructor actions highly correlated with positive attitudes with students and highly correlated with each other.  All of the results are in direct alignment with what we have been advocating in the IBL community.  Ask, listen, support, mentor.

Get the details here:

Saturday, March 30, 2013

Reminder: IBL Workshop June 24-27, Cal Poly

This post is for math instructors who teach at the college level... About half of the spots have already been taken.  If you're interested in learning more about IBL and how to implement IBL, please consider signing up for the MAA PREP IBL Workshop, June 24-27 at Cal Poly.  More information is available at www.iblworkshop.org and www.maa.org/prep.

Monday, March 11, 2013

Dealing with Student Attitudes Through the "Teaching System Lens"

One issue that doesn't get enough air-time is students' attitudes and beliefs about Mathematics.  It is documented in the Math Education literature that students often have beliefs about Mathematics and how to learn Mathematics that is either not helpful or hurtful for their own development.

I also add the caveat that no one intentionally wants the following outcomes.  They are unintended consequences, and they are consequences we should know about.  Here's a partial list of negative attitudes or beliefs that has been documented.  I've mentioned these before.
  1. Memorizing facts and formulas and practicing procedures are sufficient to learn mathematics.
  2. Mathematics textbook problems can only be solved using the methods described in the textbook.
  3. Teachers and textbooks are the mathematical authorities.
  4. School mathematics is driven by rules and memorization, and is driven by procedures rather than concepts.
  5. If a problem takes longer than 5-10 minutes, then there is something wrong with the student or the problem.
  6. The goal of mathematics is to obtain one correct answer and do it quickly.
  7. The teacher is the only source of determining whether an answer is correct or incorrect.
  8. Students’ role in the classroom is to receive knowledge by paying attention in class and to demonstrate it has been received by producing right answers.
  9. The teacher’s role is to transmit knowledge and verify that it has been transmitted.
  10. Only geniuses have what it takes to be good at mathematics.
  11. Students prefer to have only one way of solving a problem, because it is less to memorize.
  12. The processes of formal mathematics have little or nothing to do with discovery or invention.
  13. Students who understand mathematics can solve assigned problems in 5 minutes or less.
  14. One succeeds in school mathematics by performing the tasks, to the letter, as described by the teacher.
  15. The various components of mathematics are unrelated.
So when an instructor teaches via IBL and works with students who have never had an IBL experience, there usually exists a host of default expectations that one has to work through with the students.   

Let's say the students in your class are reluctant to buy into the IBL system.  Then looking at teaching as a system can provide a broader perspective to address the issues, which could lead to a more coordinated effort to get students to become active participants in their own education.

Attack this teaching challenge through content, assessment, and pedagogy (i.e. through a system approach).

Content
Course content is one of the key components.  If tasks are too hard and only the very best students are successful at solving them, then students who are more likely to have some of the negative beliefs and attitudes above will have "evidence" to reinforce them.  "I'm not going to be successful anyways, so I might as well give up after 5 minutes."

Consequently, the tasks presented to students should be matched to their levels, and having a handful of very accessible problems is almost never a mistake.  At worst, the students mow them down, and you've been able to get more students to participate.

If students are having trouble starting up or you have a subgroup that is passive and not engaged, then one tactic available is to breakdown a problem set (or a part of one) into more manageable pieces.  This method can help students get going on problems.  One thing to keep in mind is to keep problems that are more challenging to keep everyone engaged at an appropriate level.

Assessment
If assessment is setup only along traditional lines (homework, midterm, final), and assuming each of these components is implemented in the usual way, then the ethos of the IBL course is mismatched to the course assessment.  If homework is graded based on accuracy, and there are no venues for safe exploration, then students are being told implicitly that "mistakes count against you."  This can inhibit risk taking and undermine the course.  While our viewpoint from the instructor side is that we expect the exploration to take place on scratch paper, this may not be a concept and workflow practiced by students.  It's a curious thing -- students expect to write down the answer in one shot.  This is absurd in art, science, math, etc. when thinking about it.  So how did we get here?

The pristine nature of clear lectures can be beguiling.  The imagery is one of a the brilliant expert doing it right the first time. Every time.   Instructors are never seen struggling, and this is an impossible standard to achieve as a learner, especially for the ones who need the most help. The unintended consequence is that in our effort to make the best possible presentations, the notions that working hard, being willing to explore, learning from mistakes, and having the predilection to work through our own personal learning obstacles can be undermined.

Homework is an opportunity to portray doing math the way mathematicians do it. One option is to provide feedback but not grade the homework in the usual way with numerical scores.  The explicit message that should be given to students is that their effort and the quality of their exploration is being checked, and feedback will be given to them to assist them with the learning process.  I'm not saying that this is how it should always be done, but this is an idea worth considering and adapting for your own courses.   If your goal is to bring about change in student perceptions in math, then grading homework for process and effort is one of the available tools.

Grading presentations is valuable.  In courses where presentations are used regularly, presentation grades should be reflected in final course grades.  Students are being asked to share their ideas, a noble thing indeed, and the quality of this work should be reflected in their course grades.  A level around 25% works well in lower-level courses. As courses become more proof oriented, then raising the presentation grade as a percentage of the overall grade makes sense.  (Grading presentations and some sample rubrics will be discussed in future posts.)

Mastery-based finals are used by some IBL instructors with success.  Such exams are split into two parts.  Part 1 consists of material that anyone who passes the course should know.  Part 1 is contains the fundamentals and essential basics.  Students should be able to complete the entirety of part 1.   Part 2 is an opportunity for students to raise their grades.  Part 2 contains problems that require applying knowledge to problems novel to the students.  (Parts 1 and 2 are given to students at the usual examination time.)  A final exam structured like this allows students opportunities to demonstrate that they have learned the material and can demonstrate that they can use what they learned to solve problems new (to them).  Before the final exam, students are given a (non-final) course grade going into the final exam.  Passing part 1 means students keep their grade OR get at least a C- in the course.  Success on part 2 only improves the final grade and does not count against students (i.e. non-negative help).

Why do mastery-based final exams make sense?  If we value learning, applying ideas, and self-improvement, then mastery-based finals are a form of assessment of mathematics aligned to these values.  Further it provides an incentive for students to work hard through the end of the course, because they have a chance to succeed right up to the very end.   It is also noted that this does not mean one lowers standards.  The idea here is to keep the standards at the usual level, but provides a structure and incentives for students to achieve these standards.

The three main examples (effort/process based homework, assessing presentations, and mastery-based finals) are ways we can align assessment of the usual assessment items to IBL classes.  Additionally instructors can use portfolios, reading assignments, and reflective writing (journaling) as additional forms of assessment.  These assignments do not need to be large part of the final course grade, and are valuable tools for gathering data about how your students think.  Gathering formative assessment is significantly valuable, and all instructors are encouraged to use one or more of these additional strategies to help put together the full picture.

A specific example I want to share is journal assignments.  Specifically this example is about using "The 5 Elements of Effective Thinking," by Burger and Starbird as a vehicle for students to think about their own thinking (metacognition).  When working with a group of students who do not like mathematics (e.g. Math for Liberal Arts), then having students read and write about healthy ways of doing math is a successful strategy for combating math anxiety and buy-in.  Math autobiographies are normally the first assignment, and the rest of the assignments are based on chapters from the book.  A typical assignment asks students to (a) read the assigned chapters, (b) write about 2-3 things they learned, and (c) write a personal reflection about how they are doing math.

For students in education courses, such as "Math for Elementary Teaching," I use a variety of articles from Teaching Children Mathematics, and books like "What's the Point of School?" by Guy Claxton, and "What's Math Got to Do With It?" by Jo Boaler.   Students in math major courses could read autobiographies of famous mathematicians, books like "Fermat's Enigma" by Simon Singh, or other related books.  A vast array of possibilities exists with journal assignments, and you are encouraged to find (and share!) strategies that work for you.

One last facet of assessment is that it needs to be set before the term starts.  Assessment is the least flexible component, once the term gets rolling.  Thus, it is worth thinking about assessment early in the planning phase of a course well before you meet classes for the first time.

Coaching
As mentioned in an earlier post (Link), coaching is an critical facet of teaching.  When students get stuck, then your role as an IBL instructor is to manage the classroom so that students continue to learn, as opposed to giving up.  If the default attitude or belief of your students is to shutdown when stuck, then coaching students through this phase is part of the job.
  • Coaching can be verbal encouragement.  "It's okay to get stuck.  Let's see if we can figure this one out together.  Don't give up... Being stuck is a natural, regular part of doing mathematics."
  • Coaching can be directive. "Let's try figuring this related example/strategy/definition..." or "Let's pair up and try to see if you can think of a useful idea or draft a plan you can take home and try."
  • Coaching can be done through content. "Let's look at this supplemental handout I wrote yesterday after class, when I saw that we were all stuck on number 19.  I think these problems will be really helpful..."
A couple things to keep in mind.  Frustration levels have to be kept below "redline," and students may need to learn specific strategies and habits of mind.  IBL instructors should work to stay attuned with their student and setup a friendly, safe environment, where students are encouraged to ask questions when they are stuck.  If students are quite, then asking them what they are working on is one way to check in without asking for an answer or question.

In summary, a "system approach" to dealing with a complex issue (students' attitudes about Math) provides a richer and likely a more successful approach.  Teaching and learning is complex, and there are many things that affect the day-to-day activities of our course.  At times it can be a daunting challenge, but as my colleague Professor Dylan Retsek says, "Chop wood, carry water."  In this case, we break down our response to content, assessment, and coaching.

Upward and onward!


Tuesday, March 5, 2013

Research on IBL in College Mathematics at UC Boulder E&ER

A quick post today:  Laursen, Hassi, Kogan, Hunter have produced recent work on IBL in Mathematics.  Their work thus far (and more is coming) is available HERE

Friday, February 22, 2013

Teaching is a System

When I first started using IBL, I didn't realize exactly what I was stepping into.  While I knew I wanted to get students involved with their learning, I thought I would learn about tasks or problem sequences that I could deploy and then students would *do* math under my guidance.  This is a correct model to some degree, but mainly I was thinking about the content.   I didn't completely realize that teaching is a system.

By system I mean that teaching is a set of interdependent components that form an integrated whole.  Instructor actions, course content, what students bring (intellectually) with them, and how students are assessed are some of the interdependent components.  To simplify things we can focus on three main components of the teaching system:
  • Teaching methodology (broadly defined)
  • Course content and more specifically tasks students do in and out of class
  • Assessment
Each of these components are complex, and have several subcomponents.  I'll just touch on the surface of each of these in this post, as it is beyond the scope of this post to discuss all the important details.  What I want to do here is to outline what I mean when I say that teaching is a system.

Teaching Methodology
In moving from teacher-centered to active, student-centered instruction, the instructor in an IBL (or hybrid IBL) course is to shift the focus from information transfer towards sense-making tasks.  The instructor could employ student presentations, group-work, and think-pair-share as strategies in-class to engage students in the learning process.  Teaching changes that involves students more deeply in the learning process implies that usual content has to be reformulated.  Students need different tasks to work on compared to when they receive information from a lecture.

Mathematical Tasks for Students (Content)
In the google era the objective of education is no longer focused on knowledge acquisition.  Knowing how to creatively use knowledge and effective ways of thinking rise in value.  In light of this, merely sharing insights or showing how things work is not sufficient.  Students then need different, more sophisticated tasks, which require them to think, problem solve, and communicate their ideas.  These tasks then must be designed for the specific stages of development and the variance among students in each class.  Selecting appropriate tasks relies on a knowledge of how students think, and tasks must adapt in sophistication as students develop over time.  

Assessment
Measuring success in this new paradigm then needs to change.  Merely asking students to execute algorithms or bubble in answers does not capture more sophisticated learning objectives, and does not provide proper incentives to become a better thinker.  Thus, as one switches more and more towards full IBL methods, assessments must also change in parallel to measure appropriate learning outcomes.  The simple way to put this is "Put your money where your mouth is."  If we value problem solving, communication, creativity and all those wonderful qualities of an enlightened mind, then we need to align assessment accordingly.  Specifically this means we need to add in presentations grades, adapt tests towards mastery (as opposed to showing knowledge acquisition), and course grades ought to move away from a weighted average of tests, homework, and final exam.  Some of this is controversial, and I understand both sides of the argument, especially in the case of using a weighted average.  My point here is really that instructors should ask themselves if whether a weighted average truly captures the learning they are after.  There exists, in fact, an implicit acknowledgment that the weighted average is not always useful among many (or most) faculty.  For example, it is common practice for instructors to weight the final exam more heavily if a student does better on the final.   

Assessment doesn't always have to affect final grades -- informal assessment helps guide instruction.  Interspersing activities in class to check for understanding can provide instructors with the information they need to address the specific misconceptions and learning challenges the students are dealing with.  Not only are active, student-centered activities be better for learning, they provide a wealth of information for instructors to use to guide instruction.

The Textbook is Not Enough  
Viewing teaching as a system can also help put things into perspective.  For instance, textbooks are generally overvalued as a solution method for dealing with the issues of teaching and learning mathematics.  In other words we may fool ourselves into thinking that we can solve our problems by just having "the right book."  Indeed much of the reform movement has been focused on content, and for good reason.  If we want students to know more than algorithms, then they need updated textbooks (or course materials).  That's true.  But let's say we get good materials into classes.  All we've done is change one aspect of the teaching system, and consequently we need to consider if this materially affects the way in which students interact and engage in the mathematics.   While choosing good course materials is important and necessary, it is by itself not sufficient.  And this is clear from the teaching is a system viewpoint.

We can think about this issue another way.  If it were the case that all we had to do is pick the right textbooks and then all our struggles with teaching and learning would be solved, then it would have been done by now.  Throughout history there have been enough brilliant, eloquent writers and thinkers, who have provided us with a wealth of lucid, beautifully written work.  Just because Shakespeare wrote Hamlet (and that we read it in high school or college), this doesn't mean we have all learned, internalized, and implemented the valuable lessons presented in it.

More Advanced Stuff
There are other issues that come into play that haven't been touched on in this post.  One has to consider the specific course (Calculus, Upper-Level Mathematics, Math for Elementary Teaching, Math for Liberal Arts), student attitudes and beliefs, getting students to buy-in, and so on.  The teaching is a system framework provides us a broader approach to addressing some of these challenges.  Teaching methodology, mathematical tasks, and assessment can be adjusted and developed in coordination to shift the focus on student engagement and collaboration as well as addressing issues related to student attitudes and buy-in.  More posts are coming soon that will present specific examples of how this can be done.  

Wednesday, January 23, 2013

Coaching vs. Cheerleading

I've had some nice, informative, and enlightening conversations with math instructors about the difference between coaching and cheerleading.   The discussions I had were generally about classroom management or the usual IBL questions like "How do you select presenters?" or "How do you get the quiet students engaged?"

The issue I want to bring up is somewhat subtle, and also an important one.   There are some people or personalities that react negatively or find that it is not in their nature to cheerlead.  I have no problems with this.  Cheerleading is not necessary.

On the other hand, coaching is necessary in effective IBL courses.  A problem a new (or even experienced) IBLer can run into is confusing coaching for cheerleading.  This takes on at least two forms.  Some don't coach since they are not inclined to be a cheerleader.  Others think they are coaching when they are really cheerleading.

Let's discuss some examples to sort out the differences.  Cheerleading examples:
  • "Good job!"
  • "High Five!"
  • "You can do this!"
  • Here's me showing how much I am excited about the subject!  Don't you just love this proof?!?!
Cheerleaders are supporters.  They give high fives and can positively affect the environment.  They root for the players.  Cheerleaders, however, do not affect the results of the play on the field directly by their actions, although they do contribute to a more positive environment.

Coaching examples:
  • Noticing where students are struggling and creating a new task to bring out the issue so that students can engage in making sense of it.  "I noticed the following... Let's all now work on this new task..."
  • Noticing if students have reached a high level of frustration, and makes an instructional decision to deflate the pressure, refocus the students, or whatever to keep students on the learning path.  This may be the instructor making a joke initially, and then talking about how being stuck is okay.  "I hope you all know that being stuck is okay.  I know problem 3 is challenging, and it is natural to be stuck.  Let's now focus on what you've come up with and share them out.  Then we can see if there's an idea we can work with..."
  • Thanking students for their efforts and their work.  "Thank you Judy! You explained carefully using a proof by building a sequence that creates a contradiction..."

Coaching decisions affect the outcome of the game.  IBL instructor in-class teaching decisions (i.e. coaching) affects student learning outcomes.

Let's compare "Good job, Judy!" vs. "Judy explained carefully..."   Why is one cheerleading and the other coaching?  When we say "Good job!" it is praise and an evaluation (just as much as "Bad job!" is an evaluation).  Once uttered the discussion often stops there.   When we point out what Judy did and the strategies that she used, and then thank her, it highlights what Judy used to solve the problem, which other students can pick up on and learn from.  The focus is on the math and the thinking behind it.  The discussion could be extended with a follow-up task like "Explain what is important about this step of the proof to your neighbor."

Helping students get out of a rut by changing tasks, asking questions, and deflating a frustrating situation is effective coaching, because it keeps students in the learning zone.  Those who shy away from cheerleading should make it clear in their own minds the difference between coaching and cheerleading.  Adding some cheerleading on top doesn't hurt, and can create a more relaxed atmosphere, but it does not by itself create a fundamental shift in the learning environment.

In my experiences working with instructors who struggle with IBL, one of the common issues some of new IBL instructors struggle with is knowing the difference between coaching and cheerleading.  Often this is unacknowledged, and sounds like "I just don't know if I have that kind of personality."  So having the right personality then is conflated with a lack of effective observation and communication skills related to IBL teaching.  The danger here is that this means there's the assumption that nothing can be done about improving the skills and practice.  I hope that these examples help define where effective coaching lies, as well as point out that effective IBL coaching skills can be learned and employed by any math instructor.

How to get started if you're new to this?
Really, really listen to your students.  Ask students when they are working in groups basic questions like, "Can you show me what you're working on?"  Or "I would like to know how your are thinking about this problem.  Could you explain to me...?"  Then listen.  Ask follow-up questions and keep on listening.  The goal is to understand student thinking.

During or after class presentations, rather than say "Good job!"  Point out what the student did, the strategies they used, and so forth.  Next, ask the class to share what insights they gained from the student's work.  Finally thank the student for presenting as a gesture of appreciation for their effort and contribution.

Is cheerleading bad?  Well, there's some debate about this, especially in Child Development for early grades.  Generally Child Development experts agree that saying "Good job!" is counterproductive.

Effective teaching is about what we actually get students to do that is meaningful for their development.   Hence it is important that effective coaching and making good teaching decisions form the core of IBL teaching.  If you rely on cheerleading a lot, then it's time to upgrade to more coaching decisions.  If you've shied away from coaching due it feeling similar to cheerleading, then I encourage you to take a different view and try one instance of IBL coaching in your next class.


Friday, January 4, 2013

Efficiency in the Workplace

If you are the type that makes New Year's Resolutions, one thing I'd recommend you do is to spend time focusing on efficiency.  A few years ago I converted to using a to do list manager that syncs with all my iDevices.  This means that I can stay connected with the things that I need to do, I write everything down, and most importantly I no longer wake up in the middle of the night with thoughts of "Oh! I forgot to..."

1. Watch this video of David Allen ("Getting Things Done").


2. Do a "core dump" of all the things you need to do into an electronic todo list manager, such as OmniFocus.

3. When you get to your office open up your todo list manager AND do not check email.  Figure out your agenda, adjust, and (ideally) work for an hour on your stuff.  Then check email.

4. Figure out the specifics that work for you, and find the programs, apps, and system that gets you quickly and efficiently into you work mode. While I use OmniFocus, I know it's not for everyone.  It works for me, and I've made it work for me. You may prefer EverNote or some other system.

Why?  Time.  Time is the most precious resource we have, and if you are more efficient, you have more time to allocate to your teaching and research that is meaningful.  It helps you get better.  If you're always in catch-up mode, then your tasks are controlling you, and you have no margin for error. If you get sick or miss an appointment, you're way behind.